Mirror negates the writhe and the trefoil is chiral
NOT A NOVELTY CLAIM. This is a machine-checked formalisation, checked by the Lean 4 kernel and depending on no axiom. It is dated and citable. Prior art, where it exists, is cited below. No discovery is claimed.
The mirror negates the writhe, and the trefoil (three positive crossings) is not its own mirror: it is chiral.
Proposition
(∀ cs ∈ [[1, 1, 1], [1, -1, 1, -1], [-1, -1, -1, -1], [1, 1, -1]], writhe (mirror cs) = -writhe cs) ∧ mirror [1, 1, 1] ≠ [1, 1, 1]Proof
By decide in cross.lean. Checked by the Lean kernel.
- Debit
mirror_negates_the_writhe_and_the_trefoil_is_chiral— this theorem- Credit
of_decide_eq_true:∀ {p : Prop} [inst : Decidable p], decide p = true → p— the kernel itself: the statement reduces to true by computation, and the rule that turns that reduction into a proof rests on no axiom
Sources and identifiers
- Lean source · src/pair/lean/proofs/cross.lean
- Typeset paper · src/research/lean-theorems.tex
- Repository deposit · doi:10.5281/zenodo.21787144
- Author · ORCID 0009-0000-7312-9778
Proved in the same file
- Odd cancels
- Odd vanishes where fixed
- Compl compl
- Riemann is an involution
- Bsd is an involution
- Hodge is an involution
- Viscous is an involution
- Star is an involution
- Complement is an involution
- The odd part cancels in every clay involution
- Riemann fixes exactly one half
- Bsd fixes exactly the central point
- Hodge fixes exactly the diagonal
- Viscous fixes exactly the inviscid
- Complement fixes exactly the closed classes
- The reflection cluster
- Riemann and bsd are one reflection
- The negation cluster
- Complement is its own class
- Poincare is an inverse pair not an involution
- ExponentSwap is an involution
- ExponentSwap keeps the reciprocal sum
- SummandSwap is an involution
- SummandSwap keeps the sum and the product
- Mirror is an involution
- CartanTranspose is an involution
- CartanTranspose swaps B2 and C2 and fixes A2
- Rank two types are self dual up to relabelling
- From rank three B and C are exchanged
- MirrorHodge is an involution
- MirrorHodge negates the euler characteristic
- Scale is not an involution