Rank two types are self dual up to relabelling
NOT A NOVELTY CLAIM. This is a machine-checked formalisation, checked by the Lean 4 kernel and depending on no axiom. It is dated and citable. Prior art, where it exists, is cited below. No discovery is claimed.
EVERY RANK-TWO TYPE IS ITS OWN DUAL, up to renaming the roots. A₂ is fixed by the transpose itself; B₂'s transpose is C₂, and C₂ is B₂ renamed — so(5) ≅ sp(4), one type, so the swap above is a swap of matrices, not of types; and G₂'s transpose is G₂ renamed: G₂ is self-dual. (Of the Dynkin type only: the dual group also exchanges the centre and the fundamental group, which a Cartan matrix does not see.)
Proposition
cartanTranspose (2, -1, -1, 2) = (2, -1, -1, 2) ∧ cartanTranspose (2, -2, -1, 2) = (2, -1, -2, 2) ∧ relabel (cartanTranspose (2, -2, -1, 2)) = (2, -2, -1, 2) ∧ cartanTranspose (2, -1, -3, 2) = (2, -3, -1, 2) ∧ relabel (cartanTranspose (2, -1, -3, 2)) = (2, -1, -3, 2)Proof
By decide in cross.lean. Checked by the Lean kernel.
- Debit
rank_two_types_are_self_dual_up_to_relabelling— this theorem- Credit
of_decide_eq_true:∀ {p : Prop} [inst : Decidable p], decide p = true → p— the kernel itself: the statement reduces to true by computation, and the rule that turns that reduction into a proof rests on no axiom
Sources and identifiers
- Lean source · src/pair/lean/proofs/cross.lean
- Typeset paper · src/research/lean-theorems.tex
- Repository deposit · doi:10.5281/zenodo.21787144
- Author · ORCID 0009-0000-7312-9778
Proved in the same file
- Odd cancels
- Odd vanishes where fixed
- Compl compl
- Riemann is an involution
- Bsd is an involution
- Hodge is an involution
- Viscous is an involution
- Star is an involution
- Complement is an involution
- The odd part cancels in every clay involution
- Riemann fixes exactly one half
- Bsd fixes exactly the central point
- Hodge fixes exactly the diagonal
- Viscous fixes exactly the inviscid
- Complement fixes exactly the closed classes
- The reflection cluster
- Riemann and bsd are one reflection
- The negation cluster
- Complement is its own class
- Poincare is an inverse pair not an involution
- ExponentSwap is an involution
- ExponentSwap keeps the reciprocal sum
- SummandSwap is an involution
- SummandSwap keeps the sum and the product
- Mirror is an involution
- Mirror negates the writhe and the trefoil is chiral
- CartanTranspose is an involution
- CartanTranspose swaps B2 and C2 and fixes A2
- From rank three B and C are exchanged
- MirrorHodge is an involution
- MirrorHodge negates the euler characteristic
- Scale is not an involution